According to excavation director Aren Maeir of Bar-Ilan University
in Israel, the two names are remarkably similar to the etymological
Indo-European parallels of Goliath.
"It can be suggested that in 10th-9th century Philistine Gath, names quite
similar, and possibly identical, to Goliath were in use. The chronological
context from which the inscription was found is only about 100 years after
the time of David, according to the standard biblical chronology," Maeir
said in a statement.
This appears to provide evidence that the biblical story of Goliath, killed
by the Hebrew shepherd boy David with a sling, reflects the cultural
reality of the time, Maeir said.
According to Lawrence Mykytiuk, a Purdue University Bible scholar who
invented a system to determine whether ancient inscriptions apply to people
in the Bible, the pottery shard probably does not refer to the biblical
Goliath.
Mykytiuk, the author of "Identifying Biblical Persons in Northwest Semitic
Inscriptions of 1200-539 B.C.E," applied the three key questions in his
identification system — reliability of inscriptional data, setting and
matching of identifying marks — to the ceramic fragment.
"The result is no clear identification of the biblical Goliath. Even if his
name were clearly written on the potsherd, there are no other indications
that might identify or disqualify the person named on it as the biblical
warrior.
"Keep in mind that there could have been other men named Goliath
among his townsmen," Mykytiuk told Discovery News.
Nevertheless, the finding provides well-grounded cultural background that
supports the biblical narrative, according to the scholar.
"This is evidence that non-Semitic names that are remarkably similar to
Goliath were used within the time frame of this Philistine warrior in his
reputed hometown of Gath.
"This inscription supports the Bible, not with a
direct identification of Goliath, but in its historical and linguistic
background," Mykytiuk said.
Maeir will present his finding this week at the conference of the American
Schools of Oriental Research in Philadelphia.